Bought from 5 Below for $5
The package says 'shimmer' eyeliner, but they are more metallic than shimmery.
Not all of the eyeliners are true to color. Copper is more of a light gold color, and Emerald is not quite dark enough to be truly emerald color in my opinion.
Emerald, Sapphire, Silver, Lilac, and Copper
Although they are cheap-o eyeliners they are actually quite pigmented.